Short Answer
From the 1890s onward, New Thought spread across America not through grand cathedrals or centralized authority, but through the printed word. Magazines such as New Thought, Unity, and The Nautilus carried the movement’s core ideas—mental healing, the power of positive thinking, and the divinity of the individual—into thousands of homes. These periodicals were more than mere newsletters; they were the connective tissue of a decentralized spiritual revolution, shaping its theology, connecting its leaders, and building a national community. This article explores how New Thought magazines became the movement’s engine, transforming a loose collection of healers and philosophers into a lasting cultural force.
Historical Context
New Thought emerged in the late nineteenth century from a rich soil of metaphysical speculation. Transcendentalism, with its emphasis on the individual’s direct access to the divine, and mesmerism, which suggested the power of the mind over the body, laid the groundwork. Christian Science, founded by Mary Baker Eddy, popularized mental healing, but its rigid theology alienated many. Emma Curtis Hopkins, often called the “teacher of teachers,” broke from Eddy and synthesized a more inclusive idealism. By the 1890s, a diverse group of practitioners—including Phineas Quimby’s students—were experimenting with mental cure. This milieu produced a demand for literature that could explain and validate these practices. The first New Thought periodicals arose from earlier hypnotism and magnetism journals, as practitioners sought to reach wider audiences.
Main Narrative
The rise of New Thought magazines is a story of adaptation, entrepreneurship, and the power of print to unify a scattered movement. The following subsections trace the evolution of these periodicals and their role in shaping the movement.
Origins
The immediate precursor to New Thought magazines were periodicals devoted to hypnotism and suggestive therapeutics. Sydney Blanshard Flower’s Hypnotic Magazine (1896) evolved through several titles—Journal of Medical Hypnotism, Suggestive Therapeutics, and Journal of Magnetism—before becoming New Thought in 1901. This lineage reveals the movement’s roots in the mind-cure tradition. These early journals featured articles on mental healing, case studies, and advertisements for correspondence courses.
Founders
Key figures in the magazine world included William Walker Atkinson, who edited New Thought from 1903, and later Ella Wheeler Wilcox, the poet. Atkinson, a prolific author and lawyer turned New Thought advocate, used the magazine to promote his own works and those of others. The Psychic Research Company, later New Thought Publishing Co., served as the publishing arm. In Unity, Charles and Myrtle Fillmore launched Unity Magazine in 1891, which became a central organ for the Unity School of Christianity. Similarly, The Nautilus, edited by Elizabeth Towne, and later Science of Mind magazine, founded by Ernest Holmes, each provided a platform for their respective branches.
Beliefs
Magazines articulated the core New Thought beliefs: the primacy of mind over matter, the reality of spiritual healing, and the idea that individuals could shape their lives through conscious thought. They published essays, testimonials, and lessons that systematized these ideas. The journals often blended practical advice with metaphysical speculation, making the philosophy accessible to a middle-class readership.
Institutions
The magazines themselves became institutions. The Psychic Research Company, based in Chicago, published New Thought monthly. The International New Thought Alliance (INTA), founded in 1914, later served as an umbrella organization, with its own publications. Magazines also spawned study groups and correspondence courses, creating a decentralized network of practitioners.
Publications
The most influential magazines included New Thought (Chicago), Unity Magazine, The Nautilus, and later Science of Mind. Each had distinct editorial policies. New Thought, under Atkinson, was more intellectual; Unity focused on practical Christianity; The Nautilus emphasized personal success; Science of Mind presented a philosophical system. These publications often cross-pollinated, with authors writing for multiple journals.
Major Events
The 1893 World’s Parliament of Religions in Chicago, though not a magazine event, brought New Thought ideas to national attention. It also spurred the founding of new periodicals. The growth of magazines paralleled the movement’s expansion. By 1910, New Thought magazine merged into Popular Therapeutics, reflecting a shift toward broader health and success themes. Later, the movement’s magazines adapted to changing times.
Branches
Magazines helped define and differentiate branches: Unity, Divine Science (founded by Nona Brooks and Malinda Cramer), Religious Science (Ernest Holmes), and others each had their own publications. These periodicals solidified theological nuances and built loyal readerships.
Changes Over Time
As the movement matured, magazines evolved from small, personal journals to professionally edited publications. The early 20th century saw consolidation, with some merging. The rise of radio and later television reduced the dominance of print, but many New Thought magazines continue today, now with digital editions.
Present-Day Organizations
Modern successors include Unity Magazine (now online), Science of Mind magazine, and the INTA’s publications. These maintain the tradition of disseminating New Thought teachings to a global audience.
Why It Matters in New Thought History
Magazines were the primary means by which New Thought became a national movement. They allowed isolated practitioners to feel part of a larger whole, codified teachings, and attracted new followers. Without the press, New Thought might have remained a collection of local healers. The magazine culture also influenced later self-help movements, from Norman Vincent Peale to the human potential movement.
Primary Sources
- New Thought (Chicago) – Published 1901–1910, edited by Sydney Blanshard Flower, William Walker Atkinson, and others. This monthly journal is a central primary source for the movement’s evolution.
- Unity Magazine – Founded 1891 by Charles and Myrtle Fillmore. Still published, it offers a continuous record of Unity’s teachings and practices.
- The Nautilus – Edited by Elizabeth Towne, this magazine focused on personal success and practical spirituality in the early 20th century.
- Science of Mind – Founded by Ernest Holmes in 1927, this magazine remains a key publication for Religious Science.
- Hypnotic Magazine (1896) – The precursor to New Thought, showing the movement’s roots in mind-cure and hypnotism.
FAQ
What was the first New Thought magazine?
The first magazine in the direct lineage was Hypnotic Magazine (1896), founded by Sydney Blanshard Flower. It went through several name changes—Journal of Medical Hypnotism, Suggestive Therapeutics, Journal of Magnetism—before becoming New Thought in 1901.
How did magazines shape the New Thought movement?
Magazines served as the primary means of communication for a movement that lacked centralized authority. They disseminated teachings, connected scattered practitioners, built a sense of community, and attracted new followers. They also helped define theological differences among branches like Unity, Divine Science, and Religious Science.
Are any New Thought magazines still published today?
Yes. Unity Magazine continues as a digital publication, and Science of Mind magazine, founded by Ernest Holmes, is still published by the Centers for Spiritual Living. The International New Thought Alliance also publishes materials for members.
Leave a Reply