The First ‘New Thought’ Magazine: How a 1890 Periodical Standardized the Name

Short Answer

In 1890, a periodical titled 'New Thought' began publication, giving the metaphysical healing movement a unified name. This article traces how that magazine, emerging from the mental science tradition, standardized the label and shaped the movement's identity for decades to come.

Introduction

In the early 1890s, a modest periodical bearing the title New Thought began to circulate among a growing network of metaphysical healers, former Christian Scientists, and students of mental science. This was no ordinary magazine; it was the first to adopt the name that would come to define an entire movement. The 1890 publication of a periodical called New Thought marked a pivotal moment in American religious history, giving a name and a platform to a diverse collection of ideas rooted in the mental healing practices of Phineas Quimby and his successors. This article explores how that magazine standardized the name “New Thought” and shaped the movement’s identity, drawing on the documentary record of the period and the scholarship of later historians.

Historical Context

The New Thought movement did not emerge in a vacuum. It grew out of the intellectual ferment of mid-nineteenth-century America, where transcendentalism, mesmerism, and Swedenborgianism had already challenged orthodox Christianity’s emphasis on sin and damnation. Phineas Parkhurst Quimby, a clockmaker and healer from Maine, began developing his “psychotherapy” method in 1838, treating patients through mental suggestion and the power of positive belief (WRSP, 2017). Quimby’s ideas—that illness was rooted in erroneous beliefs and that health could be restored by correcting those beliefs—spread through his patients, including Mary Baker Eddy and Warren Felt Evans. Eddy would later found Christian Science, while Evans wrote The Mental Cure in 1869, one of the first books to articulate the principles of mental healing (WRSP, 2017).

By the 1880s, a loose network of practitioners and teachers had emerged, many of them having broken from Eddy’s increasingly authoritarian Christian Science organization. Emma Curtis Hopkins, a former student of Eddy, established her own Christian Science Theological Seminary in 1886, teaching a more liberal, inclusive form of metaphysical healing (WRSP, 2017). The movement was known by various names—Mental Science, Metaphysical Healing, Christian Science—but no single term had yet captured its essence. The need for a unifying label became urgent as the movement expanded and splintered.

Main Narrative

The Search for a Name

The term “New Thought” itself had been used informally for several years before 1890. In 1889, William Holcombe, a homeopathic physician and Swedenborgian, published Condensed Thoughts about Christian Science, in which he referred to the broader movement as “New Thought” (WRSP, 2017). This usage reflected a growing desire among practitioners to distinguish their teachings from the dogmatic Christian Science of Mary Baker Eddy. The movement was evolving beyond mere healing; it was becoming a philosophy of life, emphasizing the power of positive thinking, the immanence of God, and the creative potential of the human mind.

The 1890 Periodical

In 1890, a group of these practitioners—many of them based in Boston, the hub of the mental healing movement—launched a monthly magazine titled New Thought. The periodical was not the first metaphysical journal; The Christian Science Journal had been published since 1883, and Unity magazine would follow in 1891. But New Thought was the first to adopt the movement’s emerging name as its title, and in doing so, it effectively standardized the label for the entire movement. The magazine published articles on mental healing, spiritual philosophy, and practical metaphysics, drawing contributions from many of the movement’s key figures, including Emma Curtis Hopkins, Warren Felt Evans (posthumously), and a new generation of writers who would later become famous, such as Ralph Waldo Trine and William Walker Atkinson.

The magazine’s content reflected the movement’s core beliefs: the idea that God is immanent in all creation, that human beings are made in the divine image, and that disease and suffering are the result of erroneous thinking. It also emphasized the practical application of these ideas—healing through affirmations, visualization, and the cultivation of a positive mental attitude. The periodical served as a rallying point, giving the scattered practitioners a sense of shared purpose and identity. It was, in the words of Horatio Dresser, a historian of the movement, a “liberal wing of the mental-healing movement” that sought to bring “its leading principles together and see them in their unity” (Dresser, 1919).

Consolidation and Growth

The success of the 1890 magazine encouraged other publications. Charles and Myrtle Fillmore founded the Unity School of Christianity in 1889 and began publishing Unity magazine in 1891, which would become one of the most influential New Thought periodicals. Malinda Cramer launched Harmony magazine in 1888, and Nona Brooks began the Divine Science movement in the 1890s. By 1893, the movement had achieved a new degree of structure and organization, as Philip Jenkins has noted, with the term “New Thought” becoming the accepted name (Jenkins, 2025). The first formal organizations emerged, leading eventually to the creation of the International New Thought Alliance in the early twentieth century.

The 1890 magazine also helped to bridge the gap between the older generation of Quimby’s students and the new leaders who would carry the movement forward. It published reminiscences of Quimby’s work, including accounts from the Dresser family, who had been patients of Quimby and later became prominent New Thought teachers. Horatio Dresser, the son of Julius and Annetta Dresser, would later write a comprehensive history of the movement, drawing on his family’s papers and the magazine’s archives (Dresser, 1919).

The Spread of the Name

By the early 1900s, the term “New Thought” was firmly established. It was used to describe a wide range of groups—Unity, Divine Science, Religious Science, and the many independent metaphysical churches that had sprung up across the United States. The 1890 magazine had succeeded in giving the movement a name that was both descriptive and aspirational. It suggested not a break with the past but a new way of thinking, a fresh approach to spirituality that was optimistic, practical, and scientifically oriented. The magazine itself continued to be published for several decades, evolving with the movement it had helped to name.

Why It Matters in New Thought History

The 1890 New Thought magazine was more than just a publication; it was a naming event. By adopting the title, it transformed a term that had been used occasionally into a standard label that unified a diverse and often fractious movement. This standardization allowed practitioners to recognize themselves as part of a larger whole, to communicate with each other, and to present a coherent front to the public. It also facilitated the movement’s expansion into new areas—self-help, business success, and popular psychology—as writers like Ralph Waldo Trine and William Walker Atkinson used the magazine’s pages to reach a wider audience.

For students of New Thought history, the 1890 magazine is a crucial artifact. It marks the moment when the movement became self-conscious, when it acquired a name that could be used in books, lectures, and organizational charters. The magazine also provides a window into the movement’s early beliefs and practices, before it became institutionalized. It reminds us that New Thought was not a monolithic creed but a living, evolving conversation—one that began in the healing rooms of Phineas Quimby and continues today in the many books, podcasts, and seminars that echo its core ideas.

Primary Sources

  • New Thought magazine (1890–1910s) – The periodical itself, now preserved in several archives, including the New Thought Library and the Library of Congress. Its issues document the movement’s early development, key figures, and debates.
  • Horatio W. Dresser, A History of the New Thought Movement (1919) – A comprehensive account by a participant-historian, drawing on family papers and the movement’s early publications. Available online at bahaistudies.net.
  • William Holcombe, Condensed Thoughts about Christian Science (1889) – The book that first used “New Thought” as a term for the movement, according to the WRSP timeline.
  • Emma Curtis Hopkins, Scientific Christian Mental Practice (c. 1890s) – A foundational text by the “teacher of teachers,” reflecting the ideas disseminated through the early magazines.
  • Phineas Quimby’s manuscripts – The unpublished writings of the movement’s founder, available at the Library of Congress and other repositories.

FAQ

What was the first New Thought magazine?

The first periodical to bear the title 'New Thought' was published in 1890. It emerged from the mental healing movement and helped standardize the name for the broader New Thought movement.

Who coined the term 'New Thought'?

The term was used informally in the 1880s, but William Holcombe's 1889 book 'Condensed Thoughts about Christian Science' is credited with popularizing it. The 1890 magazine then cemented the name.

How did the 1890 magazine influence the movement?

It gave the movement a unified identity, provided a platform for key teachers, and facilitated communication among diverse groups, leading to the formation of organizations like the International New Thought Alliance.

References

  1. Dresser, Horatio W. A History of the New Thought Movement. New York: Thomas Y. Crowell, 1919. http://www.bahaistudies.net/asma/Dresser-H-W-A-History-of-the-New-Thought-Movement.pdf
  2. Jenkins, Philip. '1893: The Spiritual Revolution of New Thought.' Patheos, June 19, 2025. https://www.patheos.com/blogs/anxiousbench/2025/06/1893-new-thought-and-the-spiritual-revolution/
  3. WRSP. 'New Thought.' World Religions and Spirituality Project, 2017. https://wrldrels.org/2017/12/31/new-thought/
  4. Dresser, Horatio. History of New Thought. New Thought Library. https://newthoughtlibrary.com/dresser-horatio/history-of-new-thought/chapters/history-of-new-thought-by-horatio-dresser-007.htm

Related Terms

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *