Short Answer
Introduction
Thomas Troward’s Edinburgh Lectures on Mental Science (1904) introduced a distinction that would become foundational to the New Thought movement: the separation of the human mind into an objective (conscious, reasoning) and a subjective (subconscious, creative) aspect. Troward argued that the subjective mind, when impressed with a clear and felt idea, acts as the creative medium through which the Universal Mind externalizes conditions. This seemingly simple psychological model—grounded in the hypnosis experiments of his era—provided a lawful, scientific framework for what later became known as the Law of Assumption. This article examines the historical context, the concept’s development, its interpretation by various New Thought groups, and its enduring legacy.
Historical Context
The New Thought movement emerged in the mid-19th century as a reaction against both orthodox Calvinism and the mechanistic materialism of the age. Its intellectual antecedents included Transcendentalism (with its emphasis on the Oversoul and intuitive knowledge), Swedenborgianism (which posited a correspondence between spiritual and natural worlds), and the mesmerism and hypnotism experiments that fascinated European and American physicians. Phineas Quimby, a clockmaker turned healer, developed a system of mental healing in the 1850s that rejected the reality of disease as a fixed condition, arguing instead that illness was rooted in erroneous beliefs. Quimby’s ideas influenced Mary Baker Eddy, who founded Christian Science, and later Emma Curtis Hopkins, who trained many of the movement’s early leaders, including the Fillmores (Unity) and Nona Brooks (Divine Science). By the turn of the century, New Thought had become a loosely organized network of healers, writers, and lecturers who shared a conviction that mind is the creative cause of all conditions. Into this milieu stepped Thomas Troward, a retired British judge from India, whose logical, philosophical lectures offered a rigorous metaphysical framework.
Main Narrative
Definition
In his fourth lecture, “Subjective and Objective Mind,” Troward defines the objective mind as the conscious intellect that perceives the external world through the senses, weighs evidence, and makes reasoned decisions. The subjective mind, by contrast, is the subconscious, non-reasoning aspect that accepts whatever premise is given to it and proceeds to build that premise into material form. Troward emphasizes that the subjective mind is the creative power within each individual, acting under the direction of the objective mind. As he writes, “The subjective mind is the creative power within us, and it is the source of all that we call genius.” The relationship is one of control: the higher (objective) directs the lower (subjective), a principle Troward states explicitly in his second lecture: “The higher mode of intelligence controls the lower.”
Origins
Troward developed his ideas while serving as a divisional judge in the Punjab, where he studied Hindu metaphysics and the practical workings of the mind. His 1904 Edinburgh lectures were delivered to a public audience and published the same year; a revised edition appeared in 1909. The lectures drew heavily on the scientific research into hypnosis, which had been validated by two major medical schools in France (Nancy and Salpêtrière) and had become the subject of legislation in several countries. Troward used these established facts to argue that the subjective mind responds to suggestion, and that by deliberately impressing it with a desired condition, one could set the Universal Mind in motion. This was not a matter of faith or wishful thinking but of natural law.
Who Popularized It
Troward himself popularized the concept through his lectures and books, especially The Edinburgh Lectures on Mental Science and later The Creative Process in the Individual (1918). His work was widely read in New Thought circles and became a key text for the International New Thought Alliance. Among those directly influenced was Neville Goddard, who in the 1930s and 1940s built his entire teaching of the Law of Assumption on Troward’s distinction. Goddard often quoted Troward and encouraged students to “assume the feeling of the wish fulfilled”—a direct application of impressing the subjective mind. Other teachers, such as Ernest Holmes (Religious Science), also incorporated the subjective/objective split into their systems, though Holmes preferred the terms “conscious” and “subconscious” mind.
How Different New Thought Groups Understood It
While Troward’s formulation was widely accepted, different groups interpreted it through their own lenses. Unity, founded by Charles and Myrtle Fillmore, emphasized the subjective mind as the seat of divine ideas and used prayer and affirmation to impress it. Divine Science, led by Nona Brooks and Malinda Cramer, stressed the unity of the individual with the Universal Mind, seeing the subjective mind as the channel through which God’s good flows. Religious Science, founded by Ernest Holmes, systematized Troward’s ideas into a practical technique of “spiritual mind treatment,” in which the practitioner consciously aligns with the subjective mind to bring about healing and prosperity. Even Christian Science, though it rejected the term “subjective mind” in favor of “mortal mind,” shared the premise that mental states determine physical conditions. Troward’s concept provided a common vocabulary that bridged these diverse groups.
Historical Development
Troward’s lectures were published at a time when New Thought was consolidating into an organized movement. The International New Thought Alliance (INTA) was founded in 1914, and Troward’s work became a standard reference. His ideas also reached beyond the movement, influencing the human potential movement of the 1960s and the broader self-help genre. Over time, the sharp distinction between objective and subjective mind was softened by later writers who emphasized the unity of consciousness, but the core principle—that a clear idea impressed on the subconscious produces outer results—remained central. The concept also anticipated later psychological theories, including the role of the unconscious in shaping behavior, though Troward’s framework was explicitly metaphysical rather than clinical.
Related Concepts
Troward’s dichotomy is closely related to several other New Thought concepts: the idea of the “Universal Mind” as a single creative medium; the “Law of Attraction,” which holds that like attracts like; and the “power of suggestion,” drawn from hypnosis. It also parallels the ancient Hindu concept of sankalpa (intention) and the Christian mystical tradition of “prayer as affirmation.” In Troward’s system, the subjective mind is the intermediary between the individual and the Universal, and its responsiveness to suggestion explains how mental images become physical realities.
Why It Matters in New Thought History
Troward’s subjective/objective distinction gave New Thought its most rigorous intellectual foundation. Unlike earlier healers who relied on anecdotal testimony, Troward grounded his teaching in the scientific observations of hypnosis, making it palatable to a modern, rational audience. This credibility helped New Thought gain a foothold in the early 20th century and influenced subsequent teachers who sought to present metaphysical ideas as practical laws. The concept also explained the mechanism behind affirmative prayer and visualization, transforming them from vague hopes into deliberate techniques. For students of New Thought history, Troward’s work marks the moment when the movement shifted from a loose collection of healers to a coherent philosophy with a clear psychological model.
Primary Sources
- The Edinburgh Lectures on Mental Science by Thomas Troward (1904; revised 1909). The foundational text containing the full exposition of the subjective/objective mind distinction.
- The Creative Process in the Individual by Thomas Troward (1918). A later work that expands on the creative role of the subjective mind.
- The Law of Assumption (lectures and books by Neville Goddard, 1940s–1960s). Demonstrates the practical application of Troward’s concept in the Law of Assumption.
- Science of Mind magazine (Religious Science, 1927 onward). Contains articles and treatments based on Troward’s principles.
- Unity Magazine (Unity School of Christianity, 1891 onward). Reflects the adoption of Troward’s ideas in Unity practice.
FAQ
What is the difference between subjective and objective mind according to Troward?
The objective mind is the conscious, reasoning self that perceives the external world and makes decisions. The subjective mind is the subconscious, non-reasoning aspect that accepts whatever premise is given to it and works to build that premise into physical reality. Troward argued that the objective mind controls the subjective mind, and by impressing a clear idea on the subjective mind, one can set the Universal Mind to externalize that condition.
How did Troward's concept influence Neville Goddard?
Neville Goddard adopted Troward's distinction as the basis for his Law of Assumption. He taught that by assuming the feeling of a wish fulfilled—impressing the subjective mind with a felt reality—the individual would cause the outer world to conform to that assumption. Goddard often referenced Troward in his lectures and books.
Why is Troward's concept considered central to New Thought?
Troward provided a logical, quasi-scientific explanation for how mental states become material conditions, giving New Thought a rigorous intellectual foundation. His distinction between objective and subjective mind clarified the mechanism behind affirmation, visualization, and prayer, and it was adopted by major New Thought groups such as Unity, Divine Science, and Religious Science.
Leave a Reply