How Eastern Philosophy Shaped the New Thought Movement

Short Answer

The New Thought movement, which emerged in nineteenth-century America, drew deeply on Eastern philosophies such as Hinduism and Buddhism. This article traces that influence through key figures, texts, and organizations, showing how concepts like the law of attraction and meditation became central to New Thought teachings.

Introduction

The New Thought movement, a loosely organized spiritual and philosophical current that coalesced in the United States during the early nineteenth century, is often remembered for its emphasis on positive thinking, mental healing, and the power of the mind to shape reality. Yet beneath its American veneer lies a profound and often overlooked debt to Eastern philosophy. From the Hindu concept of universal consciousness to the Buddhist principles of cause and effect and meditation, New Thought thinkers absorbed and adapted Eastern ideas, weaving them into a distinctly Western metaphysical tapestry. This article explores how Eastern philosophy influenced the New Thought movement, tracing the pathways of transmission, the key figures who facilitated the exchange, and the lasting impact on the movement’s beliefs and institutions.

Historical Context

The New Thought movement arose in a period of intense intellectual ferment in America. The early nineteenth century witnessed the rise of Transcendentalism, which celebrated intuition and the inherent goodness of humanity, and the popularity of mesmerism, which linked mental states to physical health. Phineas Quimby, a clockmaker turned healer, is often credited as a foundational figure; he developed a system of mental healing that rejected conventional medicine in favor of the power of suggestion and positive belief. Quimby’s ideas, in turn, influenced Mary Baker Eddy, who founded Christian Science, and later Emma Curtis Hopkins, who became a key teacher in New Thought. This milieu was also marked by a growing curiosity about the East, as American and European scholars and travelers began to translate and popularize Hindu and Buddhist texts. According to historian Carl T. Jackson, the New Thought movement emerged alongside a broader nineteenth-century discovery of Oriental philosophy, as Westerners encountered the ancient wisdom of India, China, and Japan for the first time in accessible forms (Jackson, 1975).

Main Narrative

Origins and Early Influences

The New Thought movement’s origins are typically traced to the teachings of Phineas Quimby (1802–1866), who developed a method of healing based on the idea that illness was a product of erroneous beliefs. Quimby’s approach, which he called "Christian Science" before Mary Baker Eddy appropriated the term, relied on the power of the mind to correct these errors. While Quimby himself did not explicitly draw on Eastern philosophy, his emphasis on the mental causation of physical conditions resonated with Eastern metaphysical traditions that view the material world as a manifestation of consciousness. The broader cultural context, including the Transcendentalists’ interest in Asian scriptures, prepared the ground for the integration of Eastern ideas.

The Role of Phineas Quimby and Mental Healing

Quimby’s legacy was carried forward by his students, most notably Emma Curtis Hopkins (1849–1925), who is sometimes called the "teacher of teachers" because she trained many of the movement’s future leaders. Hopkins synthesized Quimby’s ideas with a more explicitly spiritual framework, incorporating concepts that echoed Hindu and Buddhist thought. She taught that the mind is a powerful instrument for creating reality, a notion that parallels the Hindu concept of maya (illusion) and the Buddhist emphasis on the mind as the forerunner of all things. Hopkins’s students included Charles and Myrtle Fillmore, who founded Unity in 1889, and Ernest Holmes, who established Religious Science in the early twentieth century. These organizations would become the institutional heart of New Thought, and their teachings would carry the imprint of Eastern philosophy.

Eastern Texts and Concepts

The direct influence of Eastern texts on New Thought is well documented. The Dhammapada, a collection of sayings of the Buddha, was among the first Buddhist scriptures to be translated into English in the mid-nineteenth century. Scholar Chris Anama-Green has argued that New Thought metaphysical principles, including the Law of Attraction, the practice of meditation, and the Law of Cause and Effect, can be found in the Dhammapada (Anama-Green, 2018). For example, the Dhammapada states, "All that we are is the result of what we have thought," a sentiment that directly parallels New Thought’s core teaching that thoughts create reality. Similarly, the Hindu concept of karma and the law of cause and effect found resonance in New Thought’s emphasis on sowing and reaping one’s mental seeds.

Madan Lal Goel, in his essay on the New Thought movement, notes that New Thought derives many of its principles from Hinduism, Zen Buddhism, Paganism, and Native American traditions (Goel, n.d.). He highlights the belief in "Infinite Intelligence" as ubiquitous and present everywhere, a concept that mirrors the Hindu Brahman and the Buddhist Dharmakaya. The movement’s affirmation that "true human selfhood is divine, rather than sinful" echoes the Hindu doctrine of Atman (the inner self) being identical to Brahman (the ultimate reality). These parallels were not accidental; early New Thought leaders actively sought wisdom from the East, reading translations of the Bhagavad Gita, the Upanishads, and the Dhammapada.

Institutional Development: Unity and Religious Science

Charles and Myrtle Fillmore founded Unity in 1889 after experiencing healing through prayer and mental affirmation. Unity’s teachings incorporated a positive, practical Christianity, but also embraced the idea of a universal Christ consciousness, which aligns with Eastern concepts of enlightenment. Unity published Unity Magazine, which circulated widely and included articles on Eastern philosophy. Similarly, Ernest Holmes, who founded Religious Science in 1927, wrote Science of Mind, a textbook that synthesized New Thought principles with insights from both Western and Eastern traditions. Holmes explicitly acknowledged his debt to Eastern thought, citing the Bhagavad Gita and the teachings of the Buddha as sources of inspiration. The International New Thought Alliance, founded in 1914, brought together these diverse groups under a common banner, further facilitating the exchange of ideas.

Key Figures and Their Interpretations

Beyond the founders, several other figures played crucial roles in transmitting Eastern philosophy into New Thought. Ralph Waldo Trine (1866–1958), whose book In Tune with the Infinite (1897) became a bestseller, drew heavily on Hindu and Buddhist ideas. Trine’s work popularized the concept of aligning one’s thoughts with the "Infinite Power" within, a notion that resonates with Eastern meditation practices. William Walker Atkinson (1862–1932), a prolific writer who used several pseudonyms, wrote extensively on mental science and Eastern mysticism, publishing works such as The Secret of Mental Magic and Thought Vibration. Atkinson’s writings blended New Thought with elements of yoga and Hindu philosophy, making Eastern concepts accessible to a broad American audience.

Why It Matters in New Thought History

The infusion of Eastern philosophy fundamentally shaped the New Thought movement’s identity. It gave the movement a universalist outlook, allowing it to transcend narrow sectarian boundaries and appeal to seekers of diverse backgrounds. Concepts such as the Law of Attraction, which became a cornerstone of New Thought and later of the New Age movement, are directly traceable to Eastern teachings on the power of the mind. The practice of meditation, which New Thought adopted and promoted, became a standard tool for spiritual growth and mental healing. Moreover, the movement’s emphasis on the divinity of the human self, as opposed to a sense of sin, reflects Eastern non-dualistic philosophies. Without this Eastern influence, New Thought would likely have remained a minor Christian offshoot; instead, it evolved into a global spiritual movement that continues to influence modern self-help culture, the human potential movement, and contemporary spirituality.

Primary Sources

  • The Dhammapada (translated by F. Max Müller, 1870) – One of the first Buddhist texts available to English readers; its verses on the mind and causation directly influenced New Thought thinkers.
  • Phineas Quimby’s Manuscripts (c. 1860s) – Unpublished writings outlining his system of mental healing, which formed the foundation for New Thought.
  • Emma Curtis Hopkins, High Mysticism (c. 1890s) – A collection of her teachings, blending Christian mysticism with Eastern concepts of consciousness.
  • Ralph Waldo Trine, In Tune with the Infinite (1897) – A seminal New Thought text that integrates Eastern spirituality with practical mental science.
  • Ernest Holmes, The Science of Mind (1926) – The foundational textbook of Religious Science, explicitly citing Eastern sources.
  • Unity Magazine (founded 1890) – The periodical of the Unity movement, which regularly published articles on Eastern philosophy and meditation.

FAQ

Which Eastern texts most influenced New Thought?

The Dhammapada, the Bhagavad Gita, and the Upanishads were among the most influential. The Dhammapada, in particular, provided direct parallels to New Thought teachings on the power of thought, meditation, and cause and effect, as noted by scholars like Chris Anama-Green.

How did Phineas Quimby relate to Eastern philosophy?

Quimby himself did not explicitly cite Eastern texts, but his system of mental healing, which posited that illness stems from erroneous beliefs, laid the groundwork for later New Thought leaders who integrated Eastern concepts of consciousness and the mind's power to shape reality.

What is the lasting legacy of Eastern influence on New Thought?

Eastern philosophy gave New Thought a universalist outlook, promoting concepts like the Law of Attraction and meditation that transcended Christian boundaries. This influence helped New Thought evolve into a global movement that shaped the New Age and human potential movements of the 20th century.

References

  1. Jackson, Carl T. "The New Thought Movement and the Nineteenth Century Discovery of Oriental Philosophy." The Journal of Popular Culture 9, no. 3 (1975): 523–548. https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.0022-3840.1975.0903_523.x
  2. Goel, Madan Lal. "The East in the West: The New Thought Movement." University of West Florida. https://uwf.edu/media/university-of-west-florida/colleges/cassh/departments/government/docs/archive/m-lal-goel/INDIA-in-the-West--the-New-Thought-Movement.pdf
  3. Anama-Green, Chris. "East-Meets-West: How The Dhammapada Influenced The New Thought Movement." PhilPapers, 2018. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.1324441
  4. Wikipedia. "New Thought." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Thought

Related Terms

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *